Blood Orange Polenta Olive Oil Cake & Orange Mascarpone Icing



Winter is the premier, peak growing season for citrus.  Luscious lemons, tangy limes, and fragrant oranges.  Southern Italy is known for blood oranges, considered by many to be some of the world’s finest dessert oranges.  These oranges can be recognized from other oranges by first glance at their skin’s red-blushed color.  Once opened, they surprise you by their burgundy, blood-red, ruby-colored fruit that taste a bit tart and berry-like.  Blood oranges spoil easily, so they need to be kept cool in the refrigerator for a week at the most.
To celebrate this season of citrus, I created and baked a special cake in which the star ingredients that stand out are blood oranges and their juice, olive oil, polenta (cornmeal), honey, and marscarpone cheese . . . all true to Italian cuisine.  While the cake baked and just after taking it out of the oven, my house had a delicate aroma of oranges and orange blossoms.  And during February, that scent is so fresh and welcome!
This cake has a more course, heavier crumb cake texture from the polenta (cornmeal), which is better for the orange syrup drizzled inside.  It is dense, yet moist and possesses a less sweet taste that Italians prefer.  The entire cake is balanced from the bright orange boost of flavor within.  So those of in the States might prefer this cake with a sweeter after-dinner liquor or at mid-morning with a sweet cup of tea or coffee.  This cake tastes even better after it sits for a day/evening.


The Blood Orange Marmalade (above) was ordered on-line; it’s fairly difficult to find.
The marmalade mascarpone filling truly makes all the difference to this slightly sweet cake; Italians in Italy don’t eat overly sweet desserts, but prefer those with just a hint of sweetness.  You can add more sugar and/or honey to your preferred level of sweetness though.  Or it can also be served with sweetened whipped cream, vanilla custard, or vanilla ice cream.
Blood Orange Polenta Olive Oil Layer Cake with Orange Mascarpone Filling
For the Cake:
  • 3 Blood Oranges
  • 1 cup sugar
  • ⅓ cup buttermilk/plain yogurt
  • 3 jumbo eggs, beaten
  • ¼ cup extra-virgin olive oil
  • 1-1/2 cup flour
  • ¼ cup yellow cornmeal that is used to make polenta
  • 1-1/2 tsp. baking powder
  • ¼ tsp. baking soda
  • 2 tsp. vanilla extract
  • ¼ tsp. sea salt
Orange Syrup:
  • 1 cup blood orange juice (2 blood oranges)
  • ¼ cup sugar
For the Orange Mascarpone Filling:
  • 1 Tbsp. honey
  • 1 cup sugar
  • 2 - 3 Tbsp. blood orange marmalade or juice
  • 1 container mascarpone cheese
  • ½ cup whipping cream
  1. Preheat oven to 350 degrees.
  2. Spray cooking oil on 2 eight inch round cake pans.
  3. Zest 2 blood oranges.
  4. Add zest to 1 cup sugar.
  5. Remove peel, membranes, and pith from 2 oranges. Cut into ¼" pieces.
  6. Juice the 3rd blood orange for about ¼ cup of juice.
  7. Add juice to the zest/sugar mixture.
  8. Add the buttermilk or yogurt to this mixture, whisk well.
  9. Whisk in beaten eggs.
  10. Whisk in vanilla extract.
  11. In another bowl, whisk together flour, baking powder, baking soda, and salt.
  12. Whisk dry ingredients into wet ingredients.
  13. Add orange segments, or blend them in with a hand held mixer (which I did in this case, not choosing to use large chunks of oranges).
  14. Fold in olive oil.
  15. Pour batter into pans.
  16. Bake cake for 30 minutes or until golden and a knife inserted into center comes out clean.
  17. Cool cakes in their pans on racks.
  18. Poke holes all over the top of each cake layer.
  19. Keep the cakes in their pans for the pouring of the orange syrup.
  20. 1Prepare the orange syrup:
  21. Combine the blood orange juice with sugar and boil for about 5 minutes on medium heat on the stove in a small pan.
  22. Ladle the warm syrup on top of each cake layer.
Prepare the orange mascarpone filling:
  1. Blend 2 Tbsp. blood orange marmalade into marscarpone.
  2. Add honey and sugar. Blend well.
  3. Add whipping cream until a spreadable frosting/icing consistency is achieved; otherwise it will be too thick.
  4. Sweeten the filling by adding more sugar to your taste preference.
  5. Carefully remove syrup-filled cakes from their pans.
  6. Place one cake layer on a serving platter.
  7. Spread orange mascarpone filling on top of this first cake layer.
  8. Place the second cake layer on top of the filling,
  9. Dust with powdered sugar.
  10. Garnish with mascarpone filling and sliced blood oranges.
  11. Drizzle honey all over cake and serving dish.
Share on Yummly0Pin on Pinterest83Tweet about this on TwitterShare on Facebook18Share on StumbleUpon0Share on Google+0Buffer this pageShare on Tumblr0
Thanks for sharing the LOVE!

Subscribe By Email

New subscribers receive a FREE, PRIVATE, never-before published family recipe.


  1. says

    Thanks Kirsten, it’s really good, but in a subtle way . . . my mother kept eating and picking at the cake and in 10 minutes one-fourth of the cake was gone. You have to have the filling in it though! It’s a major baking event to make this!

  2. says

    Dear Roz, I do love blood oranges. I can almost taste this cake! The marmalade marscarpone must be so good! ooh! All I can think of to say is BRAVO! Blessings, Catherine

  3. says

    Catherine, yes the the marmalade marscapone made all of the difference to us. To others, it may be too much though. But my non-Italian hubby prefers more sweet dishes than Italians, so I try to make everyone happy!

    Claudia, my mother and I nearly devoured half of it without cutting a slice!

  4. says

    Kristin, thanks for your compliments!

    LindyLouMac, I bet the blood oranges over in Italy are incredible since they are right there picked fresh without the time for shipping! MMMmmm! Enjoy!

  5. says

    Val, I think this is a cake that you’d love from all of the recipes that I’ve read on your blog! You inspired me to prepare more blood orange-based recipes!

    Patti, you said it perfectly: Fancy and different!

  6. says

    You just intrigued my whole being. This is brimming with flavor – that blood orange marmalade and mascarpone really entices and sings. This is in my future.

  7. says

    Oh my gosh Roz, this is beautiful! It has everything I love with all the fresh citrus and creamy fluffy mascarpone. A labor of love that is well worth every calorie for sure. A true masterpiece!

  8. says

    Roz my love, Oh you are speaking to my soul with this cake! I adore anything blood orange and I so look forward to january after the holiday season because I know i will be able to get my hands on cavas and bloods and meyer lemons! I love all the rare citrus! This cake with its creamy center is just calling to me and so I will be sharing it on my hearth and soul hop highlights this friday at a moderate life! Thanks for sharing it on the hearth and soul hop! All the best, Alex

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Rate this recipe:  

CommentLuv badge